Changed Status to Open

Hello @Stefan Diestelmann ,

Do you think event should be invoked even if there are no selection changes?

Thank you

There are 2 Events Item Changed and Item Selected.

If i Open the ComboBox and click on an Item i like to get a Itemselected Event

If Item Is Changed (By Selection) i think it is a ItemChanged Event . On iOS / Android its different to Windows were you get ItemChanged during Scrolling in a ComboBox.

Not getting any Event because you filter it in Control is not OK.

Answer: Yes

The initial purpose of OnItemSelected event was extended version of OnChanged event with providing details about selected item. The documentation also points on it:

<summary>
  Triggers when the user has selected another item in the list. In addition, it passes the index of the selected item and 
  the item instance itself.
</summary>

And we did alot of effort for do it for Android. I agree, that word "Selected" maybe confuse. And it had to have name like OnChangedEx instead. But now we already have what we have. I'm more inclined to believe that the selection should not be called in the same way in iOS if the selection has not been changed.

The current situation is as follows:

1. Android triggers this event for any change and for any reason. As a result, there were requests from users that this event not be triggered when it was not needed. And we had to put in a lot of effort to do it.

2. It's easier in iOS, we implement this control ourselves and we have every opportunity to make any behavior.

3. I would not like to trigger this event more often. First of all, because this event is old and it had a different meaning. And changing the logic can make changes to user projects, or force them to edit the code.

4. It would be possible to introduce a separate event that would work the way you want - When the user selects any item, even repeatedly. But the good name onItemSelected is already taken.

That's why I'm conflicted. What do you think?